This review is taken from PN Review 279, Volume 51 Number 1, September - October 2024.
Peter Gizzi, Fierce Elegy (Penguin) £9.99
A Shield against Time
Peter Gizzi’s latest collection sees the ‘I’ of the poems evolving, or at least talking about its putative evolutions, dissolutions and multiplicity. There’s a wilful attempt at being in the world, or even of slowly disappearing into it; the material of nature is unavoidable, the self porous. The result is a sort of funhouse mirror of reflection, at times: ‘Landscape is a made thing, / to see the mind seeing itself’; ‘The world is a veil. / Its effects total / the imagination’.
That ‘total’ speaks to some of what is most striking in the collection, Gizzi’s blending of registers, his bringing in at times of a slightly slangier, more casual, diction amid the philosophising (‘It was kinda real, and kinda not’). Here, and in a number of other places, it’s a welcome gear shift, puncturing what might otherwise be a too-grandiose solemnity, especially in the prose poem ‘Roxy Music’: ‘our girl asks for a poem; each week or so she says, where is my poem, you don’t write no more you sluggard; I say I don’t care… poetry don’t matter’. It doesn’t always have the desired effect, however, at times feeling strained for, even irksome. ‘Romanticism’ starts with wit, if a little archness, ‘Why not consider the squirrel / in its leafy surround? / It may be in a state / of impersonal grief / for all I know’ but descends into an arbitrary-seeming catalogue of quirkily disjointed phraselets: ‘All I see right now / is the world / playing air guitar’; ‘Yesterday I was holding / a gemstone key / but threw it into the sun / to make it impossible / to recognise ...
Peter Gizzi’s latest collection sees the ‘I’ of the poems evolving, or at least talking about its putative evolutions, dissolutions and multiplicity. There’s a wilful attempt at being in the world, or even of slowly disappearing into it; the material of nature is unavoidable, the self porous. The result is a sort of funhouse mirror of reflection, at times: ‘Landscape is a made thing, / to see the mind seeing itself’; ‘The world is a veil. / Its effects total / the imagination’.
That ‘total’ speaks to some of what is most striking in the collection, Gizzi’s blending of registers, his bringing in at times of a slightly slangier, more casual, diction amid the philosophising (‘It was kinda real, and kinda not’). Here, and in a number of other places, it’s a welcome gear shift, puncturing what might otherwise be a too-grandiose solemnity, especially in the prose poem ‘Roxy Music’: ‘our girl asks for a poem; each week or so she says, where is my poem, you don’t write no more you sluggard; I say I don’t care… poetry don’t matter’. It doesn’t always have the desired effect, however, at times feeling strained for, even irksome. ‘Romanticism’ starts with wit, if a little archness, ‘Why not consider the squirrel / in its leafy surround? / It may be in a state / of impersonal grief / for all I know’ but descends into an arbitrary-seeming catalogue of quirkily disjointed phraselets: ‘All I see right now / is the world / playing air guitar’; ‘Yesterday I was holding / a gemstone key / but threw it into the sun / to make it impossible / to recognise ...
The page you have requested is restricted to subscribers only. Please enter your username and password and click on 'Continue'.
If you have forgotten your username and password, please enter the email address you used when you joined. Your login details will then be emailed to the address specified.
If you are not a subscriber and would like to enjoy the 285 issues containing over 11,500 poems, articles, reports, interviews and reviews, why not subscribe to the website today?
If you have forgotten your username and password, please enter the email address you used when you joined. Your login details will then be emailed to the address specified.
If you are not a subscriber and would like to enjoy the 285 issues containing over 11,500 poems, articles, reports, interviews and reviews, why not subscribe to the website today?