PN Review Print and Online Poetry Magazine
News and Notes
Digital Access to PN Review
Access the latest issues, plus back issues of PN Review with Exact Editions For PN Review subscribers: access the PN Review digital archive via the Exact Editions app Exactly or the Exact Editions website, you will first need to know your PN Review ID number. read more
Poems Articles Interviews Reports Reviews Contributors
Gratis Ad 1
Monthly Carcanet Books
Next Issue Thomas Kinsella in conversation Jeffrey Wainwright comes to grips with St Chad Hsien Min Toh gives us a Korean perspective Iain Bamforth on Lou and Fritz: Sensible Shoes meets Starstruck Judith Bishop on Love and Self-Understanding in an Algorhythmic Age

This report is taken from PN Review 223, Volume 41 Number 5, May - June 2015.

The Art of Non-criticism

The Sword is Mightier than the Pen
Rory Waterman
Norman Mailer, writer and boxing fan, once famously punched Gore Vidal at a party, after receiving a negative review from him. But it wasn’t a knockout: ‘Once again words fail Norman Mailer’, Vidal is said to have retorted – proving that, though he couldn’t dance like a butterfly, he could certainly sting like a wasp. And after Vidal’s cutman pressed a bag of frozen peas to his cheek for half an hour or so (I’m editorialising here) there was, in fact, only one clear winner. Like George Foreman in the Rumble in the Jungle, the harder hitter had punched himself out all too early in the contest.

There are morals to this story, of greater and lesser kinds. Moral 1: reviewers and reviewees are bound to cross paths, and both should probably be careful as well as honest. Moral 2: reviewers might want to have a bon mot ready for when the displeased subject of a not wholly positive article decides to turn a literary bun-fight into a literal fist-fight. Moral 3: the wounded author is probably best off making a bonfire of his grievances. A writer has no right to expect lavish, untempered praise just because he has the privilege of seeing his name on the spine of a book. The most interesting books have often tended to flummox or peeve the reviewers anyway.

I’ve reviewed for as long as I’ve been publishing poems, and can’t imagine doing one without sometimes also doing the other. Being a poet as well as a reviewer has probably reminded me not to be unkind ...

Searching, please wait... animated waiting image